

Other critics, such as Roger Ebert, had kinder words for Kilmer. There was debate about the performance of Kilmer some critics charged that Kilmer, while physically fit to play Batman, more so than Keaton had been, gave a wooden performance as Bruce Wayne. Released in June 1995, Batman Forever was a success at the box office, despite receiving mixed reviews from critics. Kilmer took the role without even knowing who the new director was and without reading the script. In July 1994, Keaton decided not to return for a third Batman film after 1992's Batman Returns, due to "creative differences." William Baldwin (who previously worked with Schumacher on Flatliners) was reported to be a top contender, though just days after Keaton dropped out, Kilmer was cast.

Schumacher felt him to be perfect for Batman, though at the time, the role was still Michael Keaton's.

In December 1993, Batman Forever director Joel Schumacher had seen Tombstone and was most impressed with Kilmer's performance.
